Question:
Erolfa (mentioned earlier) is an interesting choice because of the brininess, but I think it's far too classy as a whole to be for a pirate. I mean, a pirate certainly lives ON the sea, but he doesn't bathe enough, doesn't wash his clothes, eats random and exotic things, kills things, and just generally "swashbuckles." Erolfa strikes me more as something Admiral Nelson might wear while commanding the British Fleet.
So, I'm recommending Diptyque L'autre instead. There's enough dirt, spice, kick, hints of BO, and sheer dandiness in there for any Cap'n Jack.

Answer:
Aramis Havana for Men.
It'll have ya shivverin' yer timbers mateys. Arrrrrr.

Answer:
Without a doubt, Kenzo PH.
a.

Answer:
Originally Posted by nearfantastica Without a doubt, Kenzo PH.
a. .
+1

Answer:
I find that Balenciaga's Portos is very Piratey...

Answer:
Originally Posted by castorpollux I find that Balenciaga's Portos is very Piratey... ...ooh, good one. I forgot about good ole Portos. Unfortunately, hard to find, like buried Pirate Treasure...

Answer:
Pirates Gold by Parfums Jamaica
West Indian Bay Rum
Aramis Havana pour homme
Kiss Him by Kiss
Khus Khus (vetiver) by Parfums Jamaica
Liz Claiborne Spark For Men
Lolita Lempicka Au Masculin
L'Artisan Tea 4 Two
Halston Z-14
CDG Wood Coffee
Ava Luxe Cafe Noir
Ava Luxe Kretek
Andy Tauer Lonestar Memories



Answer:
Jolly Roger by BPAL.

Answer:
Burts Bees Bay Rum cologne (easy to find too...I see it at my local drugstore next to all of the Buts Bees skin care products)
Or Idole by Lubin

Answer:
Moschino Pour Homme always associated with pirates for me!
The bottle itself also has some posh piratic feel.