Question:
Yes, I was surprised to see Euphoria. I didn't think it was that good, but having never smelled Antidote, I couldn't say it would have made a suitable substitute.
I like most of the others but Egoiste was such a surprise for me.

Answer:
Funyn how Guerlain "finally" got the nod from the voters... just when they were starting to sell out

Answer:
Originally Posted by yonggoh Funyn how Guerlain "finally" got the nod from the voters... just when they were starting to sell out Maybe this nod can encourage Guerlain to come out with a good new fragrance for men - Heritage was over 15 years ago !

Answer:
Originally Posted by Basenotes Admin Here are the w(i)nners
http://www.basenotes.net/awards/2007 Thanks to Basenotes for doing all the work!

Answer:
Suprised Vetiver took so many awards and Envy didn't. IMHO Envy is superior to Vetiver in every way. And Guerlain the #1 house? Did they even release a men's scent this year that wasn't a variation on a previous scent? Also, Euphoria #2 best new men's scent? 2006 was definitely a weak year for men's scents!

Answer:
Originally Posted by manicboy Suprised Vetiver took so many awards and Envy didn't. IMHO Envy is superior to Vetiver in every way. And Guerlain the #1 house? Did they even release a men's scent this year that wasn't a variation on a previous scent? Also, Euphoria #2 best new men's scent? 2006 was definitely a weak year for men's scents! Yea was not impressed by Euphoria for men (the ladies version plesantly surprised me tho). Burberyr London wouldve made a more apt 2nd place...

Answer:
Agree with the surprise of Euphoria that high up. I did feel Antidote might be #2. But that is just my take on it and obivously there are a lot who feel otherwise. So, I guess I will have to revist Euphoria.
I really like Egoiste, but did not expect it to be #1. Congrats to Chanel here.

Answer:
Happy to see that Cumming is getting the recognition it deserves. It really is an exceptional and unique fragrance.

Answer:
Originally Posted by manicboy Suprised Vetiver took so many awards and Envy didn't. IMHO Envy is superior to Vetiver in every way. And Guerlain the #1 house? Did they even release a men's scent this year that wasn't a variation on a previous scent? Also, Euphoria #2 best new men's scent? 2006 was definitely a weak year for men's scents! Doesn't matter. Guerlain shares a common DNA/basenote scent that unifies them as a brand. Whether they released a new scent last year or 20 years ago, no perfume house has given the world so many classic, save Creed, which didn't win, so screw 'em.
Guerlain is the MOST FRENCH, most classic, most revered and most innovative perfume house in the world, and I celebrate their win.

Answer:
Originally Posted by Rebelwithoutaclue
Guerlain is the MOST FRENCH, most classic, most revered and most innovative perfume house in the world, and I celebrate their win. And I couldn't agree more. I can't think of a house I hold in higher esteem.