Question:
Prada for Men is the closest I've found...and Caron Pour Un Homme

Answer:
Cologne Blanche by Dior (Hedi Slimane) - a quiet powder experience in a bottle.
Someone above already mentioned (and I second): Rive Gauche by YSL. Talcum with a lemon lifting its spirits.

Answer:
Quote: Originally Posted by Dante Not all talcum powder smells the same of course.
The last time I was at the barber the talc used was very like Rive Gauche. the only sensible answer to this question so far.
maybe we should ponder "which scent smells most like aftershave?".
dig?

Answer:
Monk by Mike Storer

Answer:
To me, Zizanie is the closest.

Answer:
Quote: Originally Posted by MikeFromManhattan To me, Zizanie is the closest. That great moment the first time I smelled Zizanie, my thoughts went somewhat as follows: " . . . Powder . . . talcum powder . . . manly talcum powder . . . beautiful manly talcum powder . . . elegant beautiful manly talcum powder . . . wonderful elegant beautiful manly talcum powder . . . rich wonderful elegant beautiful manly talcum powder . . . " And to this day I'm still adding appreciative adjectives.

Answer:
I'm surprised that no-one's mentioned Villoresi's Teinte de Neige yet...

Answer:
Quote: Originally Posted by Trebor I'm surprised that no-one's mentioned Villoresi's Teinte de Neige yet...
Yes ... definitely the most powdery frag I've ever experienced!
Although, it reminds me more of baby powder than talcum powder.

Answer:
Cabochard by Parfums Grès and the dry down of the original Aramis.

Answer:
Royal Copenhagen