Question:
I don't agree with the Carnal Flower recommendation.
Mugler A Men is rich and heavy, a little too rich and heavy.
Clive Christian X for Men qualifies. I prefer Sequoia as my overwhelming scent.
TNMA

Answer:
Probably Rich and heavy fits two qualities I really onjoy in a scent... Some good soggestions are:
Givenchy Gentleman
Chanel Egoiste, Antaeus and Pour Monsieur edt Concentrée
Ungaro III
Malle Musc Ravageur
Lutens Fumerie Turque
Cartier Must PH
Hermes Bel Ami
Rochas Lui and Man
Guerlain Habit Rouge
Dior Eau Noire
CDG Palisander and Tea
Caron L'Anarchiste
just to name some

Answer:
I'm surprised nobody's mentioned Opium PH.

Answer:
Most of my ideas have been posted already...
I'll add:
Hanae Mori HM (EdP)

Answer:
I 2nd YSL-Opium Pour Homme EdP.

Answer:
I'm not really familiar with those frags you mentioned, but here are my favorites of the "heavy" frags:
Z-14
Zino
JHL
Le 3e Homme
Santos
Newport (it is deceptively like Cool Water the first few times you wear it, then it reveals its complexity)
BdP
Cuiron
Knize Ten
Mr. 7

Vintage Tabarome is an interesting wear if you can get a decant, but I never found much occasion to wear it. Regret trading my decant away actually even if I never wore it.
K