Question:
Which of these Creeds do you like more?
1) Erolfa
2)Himalaya
3) Imperial
4) Green Irish Tweed

Answer:
Dude...none of the above. Wish there were more choices.

Answer:
Out of the choices, its Imperial (followed by GIT).

Right now my favorite Creed is Aubepine Acacia..

Answer:
Bois du Portugal is my favorite.
I have a lot of respect for the house, but in ways it's almost too easy to find something unique, bold and distinguished. This is the foundation of my respect for Creed, but it seems as if the house is absorbed as the pot of gold at the end of a rainbow or even as the holy grail of scent creators.

There are many other lesser known houses which produce equally interesting creations and I have largely overlooked many of Creed's offerings in lieu of finding them. Based on the popularity of Creed on these boards, there is little danger of missing something in the near future due to it's being discontinued...unlike those which have no air play on this site.

Answer:
So which Creed do you think is better?

Answer:
Angélique Encens or Vintage Tabarome would have got my vote.

Answer:
For me, its currently between Millesime Imperial and Bois du Portugal, so my vote would go for MI.

Answer:
not too fond of any of these, except for GIT, but I prefer REL, BdP, Baie, Orange Spice, Royal Delight, Tabarome...

Answer:
Originally Posted by tigrushka Angélique Encens or Vintage Tabarome would have got my vote. Hi, Tigs.
Vintage Tab would have gotten my vote, as well. I've never smelled the Angelique.
I had to vote for Himalaya. YES!--- It's like tap dancing in heaven.
GIT smells like BdP minus some wood notes--it's a pleasant green scent, but that's about it.
Erolfa is terrific! IF you're standing by the seashore. No I may be nuts, but I'm not making this up. Without the sea breeze it loses its romantic spell and becomes . . . what? Salt and water? Fish and chips?
Weird . . .
M.I ? Ah that purdy gold bottle and tales it was made for an Arab king! It smells a bit like slightly rotten fruit in a stagnant oasis, but in a nice sort of way---seriously. Somewhat unisex, so-so longevity.
I predict MI or GIT will win this contest.
As usual, this is merely my subjective, personal and infallible opininon.
Cheers,
Mario

Answer:
While all are pleasant I couldn't favor one or the other. BDP is the only one I really care for.