Question:
Oh my goodness.
I hate it when they use the same name for different perfumes.
The EDT and EDP are two different perfumes.
One has orange blossom and honey flower, the other has rose and peach.
And the Musk is also a different perfume. It has only the musk.
These are three different scents, or if you prefer to say it, three totally different variations on a single scent.
My teenage daughter loves the EDP.
This fragrance has a peach and rose topnote. The reason they call it a "pink chypre" or "new chypre" is because it incorporates vetiver and/or patchouli to create a dry, chypre rose note.
I think it is unfair to compare them.
The EDT is too quiet for some people.
The EDP is too loud for some people.
I have never smelled the musk.

Answer:
Originally Posted by purplebird7 Oh my goodness.
I hate it when they use the same name for different perfumes.
The EDT and EDP are two different perfumes.
One has orange blossom and honey flower, the other has rose and peach.
And the Musk is also a different perfume. It has only the musk.
These are three different scents, or if you prefer to say it, three totally different variations on a single scent.
My teenage daughter loves the EDP.
This fragrance has a peach and rose topnote. The reason they call it a "pink chypre" or "new chypre" is because it incorporates vetiver and/or patchouli to create a dry, chypre rose note.
I think it is unfair to compare them.
The EDT is too quiet for some people.
The EDP is too loud for some people.
I have never smelled the musk. Purplebird is correct!
Here are the ingredients listed for Narciso Rodriguez EDP (pink bottle):
Pink Chypre, Pink Floral, Voluptuous Woods, Soft Amber, Sheer Chypre, Flower Honey, Tactile Woods, Amber Light.
Here are the ingredients listed for the EDT (black bottle):
Honey Flower, Solar Musk, Orange Blossom, Osmanthus, Amberlyn, Vanilla, Tactile Musk, Tactile Woods, Vetiver.
Interestingly enough, the product labeled "Musc for her" (also black) appears to have the same ingredients as the EDT:
Honey Flower, Solar Musk, Orange Blossom, Osmanthus, Amberlyn, Vanilla, Tactile Musk, Tactile Woods, Vetiver.
Does this help clear things up a bit?

Answer:
Originally Posted by Kotori Purplebird is correct!
Here are the ingredients listed for Narciso Rodriguez EDP (pink bottle):
Pink Chypre, Pink Floral, Voluptuous Woods, Soft Amber, Sheer Chypre, Flower Honey, Tactile Woods, Amber Light.
Here are the ingredients listed for the EDT (black bottle):
Honey Flower, Solar Musk, Orange Blossom, Osmanthus, Amberlyn, Vanilla, Tactile Musk, Tactile Woods, Vetiver.
Interestingly enough, the product labeled "Musc for her" (also black) appears to have the same ingredients as the EDT:
Honey Flower, Solar Musk, Orange Blossom, Osmanthus, Amberlyn, Vanilla, Tactile Musk, Tactile Woods, Vetiver.
Does this help clear things up a bit?
It does. Thank you. I'm hoping my sample of the Musc for Her will arrive today, so I can try it out. What's weird is, the one I have doesn't have orange blossom listed, and yet that's what I get as a top note. Thankfully, it goes away, because I'm not that keen on it. So I wonder if I'll like the EDT if the orange blossom is a strong note. And I'm not keen on vanilla either. Hmm...
Verdict to follow! :-)
Clemmie

Answer:
Originally Posted by Clemmie It does. Thank you. I'm hoping my sample of the Musc for Her will arrive today, so I can try it out. What's weird is, the one I have doesn't have orange blossom listed, and yet that's what I get as a top note. Thankfully, it goes away, because I'm not that keen on it. So I wonder if I'll like the EDT if the orange blossom is a strong note. And I'm not keen on vanilla either. Hmm...
Verdict to follow! :-)
Clemmie Orange Blossom could still be in there hiding somewhere. The ingredients list is vague in some spots... Pink Chypre, Pink Floral, Floral Honey... These aren't too specific as to what's actually in them. I would guess that the floral honey has some orange blossom floral honey in it. But that's just a guess. That must be what's bothering me in Narciso Rodriguez-- I didn't figure it out until just now-- must be the orange blossoms! I love orange blossom, personally, but 8 days out of 10, it gives me a frontal headache!
Glad to help.

Answer:
Agree with what the others said, thed pink bottle is a bit more floral and edp, the black bottle is the first one and I have finished at least four of them and adore the edt/black bottle. It is very lasting, very easy to wear, lots of compliments, you can get a tester at Scentiments.great price, not affiliated. That is a fragrance you can wear anyplace, enjoy>