Question:
Originally Posted by Clemmie :-) Thanks again! I wonder if NR realise how much confusion they're causing with their packaging! That settles it. I had the EDT sprayed on me, and then was sold the EDP. It's just as well that I've really grown to love this fragrance, or all the confusion would make me give up on it! :-)
Clemmie Well Clemmie,
Let me tell you, the same thing happened to me with Guerlain's L'Instant. I tested the EDP, but I mistakenly purchased the EDT. I got home opened the package and realized that I purchased the wrong one. Since it was opened and it was my mistake, in taking the wrong package off the shelf, I've learned to "love" this fragrance too.
For some scents, the difference between the EDP and EDT is just concentration, the scent is the same. For others, the notes could have slight variations and there are noticeable differences between the EDP and EDT. Confusing... YES. But I think that it is a marketing ploy for us to make both purchases, especially if we love the scent in all it's variations

Answer:
Clemmie, there's a couple of auctions running on eBay for samples of the oil, one of them right in the UK. You may want to check out those if you wish to test the Musc for Her oil.

Answer:
I really don't have anything to add,but just wanted to say that I love the edt.Not too fond of the edp.I find it a littlebit less interesting.More floral.The edt is a lot woodier on me

Answer:
They have different ingredients. I didn't read all of this thread, but I have not heard one person that preferred the EDP or perfume in the pink bottle. Usually, I always go for the EDP, but in this case it was the black bottle all the way and my husband agreed. The EDT smells more musky and the EDP smells more like a floral. The pink one is supposed to be what is called one of the new pink chypres. Why? Goodness knows. Lovely is also supposed to be a pink chypre. And again, why? I don't know. I do like Lovely though. I wouldn't throw out the EDP, I just prefer the EDT with N.R.

Answer:
Originally Posted by Lady_in_Black Clemmie, there's a couple of auctions running on eBay for samples of the oil, one of them right in the UK. You may want to check out those if you wish to test the Musc for Her oil. Just bought them. Excellent! Thanks, I'm starting to really love it here! :-)
Clemmie
--------------------------------------
Originally Posted by ineespenes I really don't have anything to add,but just wanted to say that I love the edt.Not too fond of the edp.I find it a littlebit less interesting.More floral.The edt is a lot woodier on me It's the woodiness that I remember about it. And it had spice, and musk, and all kinds of warmth to it. Those are the fragrances I tend to be drawn to. It's odd, but I buy florals and chypres, and yet the fragrances I find myself always going back to are the ones that are a bit 'different' due to the wood notes.
Now that I've ordered a couple of samples of the oil (which I know is distinctly different now), I'll be able to comment on how different that one is too.
Clemmie

Answer:
TDDanae, the additional note in the EDP is rose.
I found it odd they chose ROSE to add to a scent which had no obvious hint of it in the 'original' EDT release. Not totally unpleasant, but I agree - the EDT is 200% my preference for the Mrs.

Answer:
I am another one who loves the EDT and the Musk for Her (the bottle of that one doesn't have the thin clear edge the black bottle of the EDT has and is theefore completely opaque).
I see the concentrations and packaging have been broken down nicely, so I won't elaborate.
If you want a sample of the musk oil, PM me with an addy:-)

Answer:
I thought they added a peach note to the EdP for some reason, but I could be wrong.
While I generally go for EdP, I, too, much preferred the EdT. I have not tried the Musc For Her. For Her EdP has a roughness to it that reminded me of Lovely, although of the two For Her EdP is softer to my nose. For Her EdT was noticeably different, both nicer and easier to wear for me.

Answer:
Originally Posted by helg I am another one who loves the EDT and the Musk for Her (the bottle of that one doesn't have the thin clear edge the black bottle of the EDT has and is theefore completely opaque).
I see the concentrations and packaging have been broken down nicely, so I won't elaborate.
If you want a sample of the musk oil, PM me with an addy:-) Thank you so much for the offer (this site is wonderful, the people are so kind!), but I've ordered some from Ebay now...a couple of 1.5ml bottles...and I should have it soon. I'm excited to try it out now!
Clemmie

Answer:
Another declared EdT-version lover here... enjoy your new finding...! ;-)