Question:
Seriously.
I saw this new cheapie at Walgreens today... it smelled pretty vile, but not like the original. Whereas Dana's regular English Leather just smells bad, this smells both cheap and offensive. Has anyone else seen this yet?
P.S.: If Hai Karate were still on the market, would we be seeing "Hai Karate Black Belt"?

Answer:
Originally Posted by MFfan310 Seriously.
I saw this new cheapie at Walgreens today... it smelled pretty vile, but not like the original. Whereas Dana's regular English Leather just smells bad, this smells both cheap and offensive. Has anyone else seen this yet?
P.S.: If Hai Karate were still on the market, would we be seeing "Hai Karate Black Belt"? I tried some of this stuff on at Walgreens too; the initial blast was cheap and vile. However, it dried down to warm, subtle and nice on my skin. Not the longest lasting stuff, but worked well with my individual body chemistry and was a pretty good bargain for ten bucks.

Answer:
haha this is getting ridiculous. I can't wait for Old Spice Black and Black Canoe.

Answer:
Sounds like a damn shame. I rather like the original stuff, and to some extent better than my scent du jour, REL.

Answer:
Originally Posted by MisterK Sounds like a damn shame. I rather like the original stuff, and to some extent better than my scent du jour, REL.
Wanna swap the REL for some Dana ?

Answer:
Hey, like MisterK I'm a fan of English Leather! It's a little cheap smelling, and it fades away into something ugly (though frankly most fragrances that aren't from a niche house, or Hermes or Bvlgari dothat in my experience) but it's great - does anyone know of a more snooty version of it? I always thought Royal English Leather would be the one, but I guess not.

Answer:
Brut Black

Answer:
I'm also a fan of the original.....My son who is 26 thinks it is a very nice scent also.....He's a scent junky too.....of course.....The apple doesn't fall to far from the tree.....LOL....Gary

Answer:
By the way MisterK - what is it you don't like about Creed's English leather vs the cheap Dana stuff?

Answer:
Originally Posted by GAIVS IVLIVS CAESAR By the way MisterK - what is it you don't like about Creed's English leather vs the cheap Dana stuff? Caesar, please see my response here /showthread.php?t=194652 since I managed to bring the thread off topic. K