Question:
Which one would be lighter more everyday scent? I read someone's comment somewhere that XS is much like Light Blue? Any comments on either?
thank you

Answer:
Similar frags to XS are HIMALAYA & HERRERA..

Answer:
I know both XS (it was my favourite for a long time) and Light Blue (my former girlfriend liket to wear it), and, to me, they are very different (that was not the reason we broke up, btw... ).
I find Black XS somewhat strange. As a XS (original) fan, I don't like the fact that it is called XS actually. To me, black XS smells mostly like strawberries, but quite an artificial smell. Perhaps it's my skin. Perhaps it would be better as a feminine scent.
As a lighter everyday scent? None of them. XS has a musky drydown that isn't light. Black XS is a heavy and sweet synthetic frag (I'm sure some will disagree with this).
Since you're a woman (who likes to wear masculine scents, I presume), I cannot recommend any of them as a substitute for Light Blue. Herrera perhaps would fit the bill.

Answer:
Originally Posted by smeller Since you're a woman (who likes to wear masculine scents, I presume), I cannot recommend any of them as a substitute for Light Blue. Herrera perhaps would fit the bill.
You made me giggle - no I dont wear these scents, I have been buying a bunch for my hubby, and since he is not really into this and doesnt care too much what I spray on him, I want to cover him with something I like.
I like strawberries, but not sweet scents. I do love musky scents on a guy, though perhaps XS is the one I want. Black XS in the mail on its way to me (hopefully) and I found XS at a good price but would have to snatch it up before the Black XS would even arrive at my door.
Thank you for your input.

Answer:
For your hubby? Sorry, Pookyface, I just thought you were one of these girls who like to wear men's scents.
Yes, perhaps XS will please you. Good luck.

Answer:
If your hubby is like mine, he will love Black XS - read my Black XS 'experience' thread from 2 weeks ago:
/showthread.php?t=193227


Answer:
I love Black XS

Answer:
another blacK XS fan..
i cant stand the original XS make me feel an strong headache...

Answer:
Originally Posted by Pieter I've been wearing this beauty for a week in a row now and can't seem to get enough. That was almost a year ago and I still wear Black XS frequently. The initial strangeness of the scent has disappeared; today I wear it with the pleasurable ease of thorough familiarity. A keeper and a future classic.
/showthrad.php?t=168525

Answer:
For me XS is a nice light daywear fragrance. I wear it at the office and personally, I don't think It's so sexy as the advertisements seem to persuade us...
Black XS is a fun mix of strawberries and woody, good for clubbing but can't be compared to the richness of some sexy beasts as M7, L'Instant etc.