Question:
Before I discovered Bel Ami (read my highly regarded review) I had reached the heights of my mid-20s fragrance experience with Polo Crest, and thought it was great. It still haunts a few "off price" stores around NYC and I was once tempted to pick it up, but am saving my dough to get Clive Christian 1872 (around 2072).
Still think well of Crest. I was too snooty for plain old Polo.
Joe

Answer:
I have a large, new bottle of Crest but find it quite weak and fleeting.
Double Black is an improvement on the original Black, IMO...more interesting and not quite as mainstream.
The original rules.

Answer:
I used to like Black.. but I got sick of it. Right now I like Romance Silver and Blue.
Hows Purple like? I wouldn't mind trying it.

Answer:
My favorite would be Polo Green. Very nice. I also remember wearing Polo Crest in High School...now that was surprisingly good. Come to think of it, I rocked a lot of Polo back in the day and I liked them all a great deal. Safari smells wonderful (my brother still wears that) and Blue is a great summer scent. But for the weather right now, at least here, I would have to say Polo Green.

Answer:
1. Safari
2. Polo Green
3. Purple Label
4. Polo Double Black

Answer:
The original Polo rocks.
- Rich

Answer:
Safari
Polo (Green)
Romance
Romance Silver
Polo Blue

Answer:
My favorite Polo is the original one.
I think it's mostly because of sentimental reasons instead of actually loving the scent itself, but i do think that it's a good one too.

Answer:
From Ralph Lauren:
1. Romance Silver
2. Polo Blue
3. Purple Label

Answer:
Wait a minute...is this a Ralph Lauren house survey or a Polo question?
Among the Polos, I've used Polo Sport more than anything in my life. That said, I think the 1978 Green is the finest. Best scent and composition. It doesn't work in hot weather, but IS sublime in cooler weather.
Number three is Polo Sport Extreme. Sadly underrated. Not in the overall scope of cologne, but out of the Polo line.
Polo Blue did nothing for me. It's inoffensive. That's the best I can say. Read Scenteur7's comment. Represents the beginning of the end of this once great house. Well...the end for integrity. Actually the beginning of more profit...
The little Crest I tried was good, like Green mixed with Safari, maybe...
(I love Safari, but it's technically not a Polo...it's RL. Not everything from RL is a Polo. God in heaven knows that Chaps is not an entry in the Polo line.)
When I get Black, I'll decide on that. Seems like another Blue, but you know..."edgy safe".