Question:
I've tried Loreal, Clinique and Estee Lauder non-oily but they just don't perform as well.
I take my eye make-up off just before cleansing so I don't mind the oily residue.

Answer:
Oh my gosh, do not spend so much for make-up remover! Neutrogena Extra Gentle Cleaser (has a very light creamy consistency) with the soft cotton pads from the Body Shop works really really well - gets the stubborn DiorShow mascara off my lashes with minimal stress on my eyelids!

Answer:
Originally Posted by StellaL I'm also looking for one that doesn't contain oil so that I don't have to rinse afterwards (i.e. any two-phase one would be unsuitable)
Any recs?
I use simple conditioning eye makeup remover. It removes waterproof mascara, and its 100% oil free. You can buy it from priceline!

Answer:
The Body Shop camomile remover is really good. It comes in a gel form and a milk form- really good!!

Answer:
Originally Posted by lil_lil I use simple conditioning eye makeup remover. It removes waterproof mascara, and its 100% oil free. You can buy it from priceline!
Does this one sting your eyes?

Answer:
the loreal one is good but i have a natio sensitive skin one that is really good too. My eyes sting if i use the loreal one too often

Answer:
Loreal is great, but I really like the johnsons makeup remover pads - they're 7.99 and work wonders!!!

Answer:
Love the Clarins gentle one - it's a non-oily one and I personally prefer it to the bi-phase one.

Answer:
I find that the Loreal one is good, but it takes quite a few swipes and still leaves some mascara at the base of my lashes and also its so hard to take off my black stila smudge pot. I have just ordered the smashbox cleansing oil, as I think an oil of some sort is the best way to solve my problem. I hope this stuff is good.

Answer:
Originally Posted by Spinkle I find that the Loreal one is good, but it takes quite a few swipes and still leaves some mascara at the base of my lashes and also its so hard to take off my black stila smudge pot. I have just ordered the smashbox cleansing oil, as I think an oil of some sort is the best way to solve my problem. I hope this stuff is good.
Sprinkle can you give me an update on the SB oil when it arrives? I am interested in what you think of it.